Egypt/Palestine : The Wall of Shame
By Tariq Ramadan
It is common knowledge that the Palestinians have long been direct victims of the directionless, spineless and hypocritical polices of the Arab leadership. It is equally common knowledge that the State of Israel need make no effort to impose its vision, its methods and its objectives. Given the support of the United States, Europeâ€™s guilty silence and the compliant passivity of the Arab regimes, we know what to expect. The foreign policy of most Arab states has been described with good reason as â€œpro-Zionist.â€ Their cowardice and treachery comes as no surprise.
Following last yearâ€™s murderous attack on Gaza by Israeli forces, we may have thought weâ€™d seen the worst. That judgment failed to take into account the ingenuity of the â€œworse yetâ€ scenario produced by the Egyptian regime and the â€œreligious authoritiesâ€ of al-Azhar. In the name of â€œnational securityâ€, of the fight against â€œterrorismâ€, and ultimately, of combating â€œcorruptionâ€, â€œsmugglingâ€ and â€œdrug traffickingâ€, the Egyptian government is building a wall reaching twenty meters below ground level to stop the â€œGazansâ€ from carrying out their â€œillegalâ€ activities and from digging â€œsmuggling tunnels.â€ Of course, the Egyptian government has no intention of confining the inhabitants of Gaza to their hell; of course, the measure is dictated only by concern for national security! So persuasive is the argument that the committee of religious experts of al-Azhar quickly endorsed the government decision, declaring it to be â€œislamically legitimateâ€ (â€œin conformity with the Shariâ€™aâ€) for the country to protect its borders. (The al-Azhar scholars were responding to a fatwa issued by the International Union of Muslim Scholars that had ruled the exact opposite, that the Egyptian decision was â€œislamically unacceptable.â€)
For shame! So this is how justice is mocked, how power and religion are misused. The Palestinian people, and most of all the inhabitants of Gaza, are denied their dignity and their rights; deprived of access to food, to water and to basic health care. And now, the Egyptian government becomes the ally of Israeli policy at its worst: isolating, strangling, starving, and smothering Palestinian civilian life after having eradicated hundreds. The aim is clear: to choke off all resistance and to destroy its leadership. The Egyptian government has blocked convoys attempting to deliver badly needed aid to the Palestinian people in an effort to raise the siege of Gaza. The mobilization that brought hundreds of women and men from around the world to Rafah was met by refusal upon refusal by the Cairo authorities, along with a strategy of selective humiliation.
For shame! No wonder the Israeli government purring with contentment. After all, a new and â€œpromisingâ€ start for the â€œpeace processâ€ has been announced! There will be something for everybody: the United States, along with Saudi Arabia and Egypt has spared no efforts to draft a new and â€œcomprehensiveâ€ program. A splendid â€œpeace processâ€ indeed, in whose name civilians have suffered months of blockade before their leaders are invited to take their place at the â€œfreeâ€ and â€œrespectfulâ€ negotiating table. Israel can keep on purring: it can play for more time without making the slightest concession. Settlement activities are to be temporarily frozenâ€”except for construction projects already underway. Finer negotiations would be hard to find!
It cannot be repeated often enough: the Egyptian â€œnational security wallâ€ is a wall of shame. The religious authorities that have legitimized it have behaved exactly like the notorious â€œulamaâ€ (Muslim scholars) or â€œIslamic councilsâ€ that openly serve power, whether of dictators or the forces of colonialism, or of some self-styled Republic specializing in the manipulation of religion. What can possibly remain of their credibility after issuing a â€œpolitical fatwaâ€ that lends the Islamic endorsement of craven scholars to the power of dictatorship? Silence would have been far better.
We must condemn these unacceptable acts, and stand beside those who resist with dignity. If successive Israeli governments know one thingâ€”with which we must agreeâ€”it is this: the Palestinian people will not surrender. For those who may still harbor doubts, we must add a second certainty, that of time: History is on the side of the Palestinians; it is they who represent, today and tomorrow, hope for the noblest human values. To resist oppression, to defend oneâ€™s legitimate rights and oneâ€™s land, to never yield to the arrogance and to the lies of the mighty. As for the power of the Israelis, the Egyptians and others, as for the fatwas of government-appointed ulama, these things too will pass; they will pass, and will be forgotten. Happily forgotten. For the duty of memory is transformed into forgetfulness when it comes to the names and the acts of dictators, traitors and cowards.