Courtesy Ben Fox, AP
|These are two sketches based on Mr. Sami Al-Hajâ€™s two part drawing on force-feeding of prisoners at Guantanamo. Please see these images with Mr. Al-Hajâ€™s explanations of them at: www.no-joke.com/sami4.htm.|
SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) â€” Three years ago, the man known as Internment Serial Number 669 stopped eating.
Ahmed Zaid Zuhair, a compact 43-year-old with 10 children in Saudi Arabia and Yemen, had been held at Guantanamo Bay since 2002 without charges and decided to join a mass hunger strike in protest. The U.S. military was determined not to let him succeed.
Since then, according to court documents reviewed by The Associated Press, guards have struggled with him repeatedly, at least once using pepper spray, shackles and brute force to drag him to a restraint chair for his twice-daily dose of a liquid nutrition mix force-fed through his nose.
The documents, filed in federal court in Washington, are a rare look at the military tactics used on hunger strikers, which have sparked international condemnation but remained hidden from view, with officials refusing to even confirm the identity of the men taking part in the protest.
Zuhairâ€™s attorney, Yale Law School lecturer Ramzi Kassem, says the tactics described in the documents amount to â€œcruel, inhuman and degrading treatment.â€ The military says the only reason it uses such tactics is that Zuhair is violent and dangerous.
â€œISN 669 has a very long history of disciplinary violations and noncompliant, resistant and combative behavior,â€ according to Army Col. Bruce Vargo, commander of Guantanamo Bayâ€™s guards.
Zuhairâ€™s protest is the remnant of a mass hunger strike at Guantanamo Bay that began in the summer of 2005, with prisoners celebrating the 10 Irish Republican Army and Irish National Liberation Army militants who starved themselves to death in Britainâ€™s Maze prison in 1981 while demanding political-prisoner status.
At its peak, there were 131 prisoners refusing meals at the U.S. Navy base in Cuba. The U.S. began force-feeding prisoners, but some were regurgitating the liquid-nutrient mix. In January 2006, commanders adopted a practice borrowed from American civilian prisons of strapping detainees into a special restraint chair for the feedings, and the number of strikers quickly dropped off.
Eventually there were just two: Zuhair and another Saudi, Abdul Rahman Shalabi. The number has since fluctuated and 12 were participating on Friday.
A number of prisoners have alleged brutal treatment during the hunger strike, and lawyers and human rights groups have accused guards of using unnecessary force. Kassem and other attorneys say their clients have mostly complied with the force-feeding, and that the U.S. has used rough treatment in an effort to break the strike.
Physicians for Human Rights, the World Medical Association and the United Nations, among others, have condemned the use of restraint chairs and other tactics. In a 2006 protest, Physicians for Human Rights said â€œthe infliction of pain and suffering to discourage a hunger strike violates U.S. law and basic principles of human rights.â€
The U.S. military has denied any abuse, though it has offered few if any details about what happens between guards and prisoners behind the coiled-razor wire.
Navy Cmdr. Pauline Storum, a spokeswoman for the detention center, said Friday that the military was required â€œunder federal law and Department of Defense policy, to preserve the health and well-being of all detainees under our control.â€
â€œWhen a detainee refuses to comply with guard instructions to leave his cell in order to receive necessary medical care, we will use the minimum force necessary â€¦ in order to preserve life,â€ including by tube feeding, she said.
And while the U.S. considers the detainees â€œenemy combatantsâ€ for whom the Geneva Conventions do not apply, it maintains it treats them in a humane manner that in some ways exceeds international standards.
The court documents, affidavits and filings recently submitted as part of Zuhairâ€™s challenge of his confinement provide the first detailed picture of his struggles with guards.
On the evening of July 17, for example, two Navy sailors took Zuhair to be fed. When they finished, they say the 5-foot-5, about 136-pound, Zuhair violently squirmed to avoid being taken back to his cell. He cursed at them and said his shackles were too tight.
They searched him for contraband and put him back in his cell, they said, and he responded with chilling words:
â€œCome in my cell, I will cut off your head,â€ he said in English, according to their account. â€œYou are scared. I can tell. Come in my cell. I will cut off your head.â€
Four weeks later on Aug. 14, Zuhair refused to come out of his cell for a force-feeding in what his lawyer described as a protest against rough treatment of the hunger strikers.
Five guards strapped on body armor, helmets and face shields and went in for him. One guard shot pepper spray through a hole in the door, but Zuhair knocked away the can. The five men wrestled him to the ground.
â€œHe fought briefly with the guards before five of them were able to place him on his stomach,â€ an officer said. â€œIt took an additional several minutes to shackle ISN 669.â€
The court documents describe other clashes involving Zuhair. One day in June, he â€œbecame aggressive and tried to break freeâ€ from guards, the military said.
Navy Capt. Bruce Meneley, the doctor in charge of prisoner care, said wounds on Zuhairâ€™s head and face were stitched up after â€œscufflesâ€ with guards in April 2003 and January 2007.
Zuhair was captured in Pakistan and taken to Guantanamo in June 2002. He has not been charged with a crime, although the military says he trained with the Taliban and al-Qaida in Afghanistan and was a member of an Islamic fighting group in Bosnia in the mid-1990s that received money from Khalid Sheikh Muhammed, the confessed mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks.
The U.S. has also claimed he was involved in the November 1995 shooting death of an American U.N. employee, William Jefferson of Camden, N.J., in Bosnia.
Zuhair denies the allegations. In addition to seeking his release, his legal team has asked for his medical records, an examination by an independent doctor and surveillance video that might support his claims of mistreatment. The U.S. military has refused.