Hidden War Dead: Iraq
Courtesy Howard Witt, The Chicago Tribune
More than 770 civilians working for US firms have lost their lives supporting the military in Iraq, and some families are now speaking out.
Houston – Like thousands of other Americans who have served in Iraq since the U.S. intervention began four years ago, Walter Zbryski came home in a coffin. Only his coffin was not draped in an American flag or accompanied by a military honor guard.
Instead, the mangled body of the 56-year-old retired firefighter from New York City was shipped back to his family in June 2004 in the bloodied clothes in which he died, with half of his head blown away, according to Zbryskiâ€™s brother Richard.
â€œI viewed the body,â€ Richard Zbryski said. â€œWhat really upset me was that he was laying there floating in at least 6 inches of his own body fluids. They didnâ€™t even clean him up for us.â€
Zbryskiâ€™s death was not counted among the official tally of more than 3,200 American military personnel who have been killed in Iraq, nor was it noted by the Defense Department in a news release. Thatâ€™s because Zbryski was not a soldier-he was a truck driver working in the private army of hundreds of thousands of contractors hired by the Pentagon to support the logistical side of the massive American war effort in Iraq.
More than 770 civilian contractors working for American companies have died in Iraq since the U.S.-led invasion began on March 20, 2003, according to an obscure office inside the U.S. Department of Labor, which loosely tracks the figures. If those deaths-of truck drivers and cooks, laundry workers and security guards-are added to the military toll, the human cost of the U.S. war effort in Iraq is nearly 25 percent higher.
Now the family members of some of those American workers killed and injured in Iraq are raising their voices, complaining that the contributions of their loved ones have been forgotten by the U.S. public. Some allege that the workers were put in harmâ€™s way without adequate protection. Others charge that their own financial and psychological hardships have been ignored by the contracting companies that promised to help them.
â€œI think these deaths are glossed over and swept under the carpet,â€ said Hollie Hulett, whose husband, Stephen, 48, was killed in an ambush in Iraq on April 9, 2004, while driving a truck for KBR, formerly Kellogg, Brown & Root, a subsidiary of oil services giant Halliburton. â€œI donâ€™t think anybody, including the Pentagon and the companies that hire these contractors, want it to be known that it is that dangerous over there and they are sending them out into a mess.â€
Critics of the war, and some members of Congress, have begun pressing the Bush administration to disclose more details about the Pentagonâ€™s reliance on private contractors to pursue the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Defense Department officials conceded in congressional testimony last year that they do not keep track of how many contractors are at work in Iraq and Afghanistan or how many casualties they have suffered.
â€œWe want to know how many contractors and subcontractors there are, the total cost of the contracts, the number of dead and wounded contractors,â€ said Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.), who has introduced a bill to require the Bush administration to collect and publicize such information. â€œThis is basic information…. When you donâ€™t even count [the contractor deaths], you mask the cost in life of this war.â€
The most common estimate of the number of contractors currently working for U.S. firms in Iraq is 100,000, according to military analysts, but that figure includes unknown proportions of Americans, Iraqis and citizens of other countries.
The most recent statistic for deaths among those contractors is 770 as of the end of 2006, according to the Longshore and Harbor Workersâ€™ Compensation Division of the U.S. Labor Department, which computes the figures from workersâ€™ compensation claims filed under the federal Defense Base Act.
But those figures, which also count 7,761 contract workers injured in Iraq, appear to understate the actual number of casualties because they do not include killings of off-duty workers. Nor do they specify the nationalities of the dead and wounded.
What is more clear is that KBR, the Houston-based company that holds the largest Pentagon services contract, has more than 50,000 employees and subcontractors at work in Iraq, Afghanistan and Kuwait who are driving fuel and supply trucks, cooking meals, delivering mail and generally supporting the U.S. military in the region. So far, according to the company, 99 KBR employees have been killed on the job, most of them in Iraq.
The war-zone jobs come with health and other benefits and are high-paying – contract workers in Iraq can earn $80,000 or more, most of it tax-free-and KBR has more than 500,000 applications from interested workers. But company officials insist that they provide repeated and explicit warnings about the dangers in Iraq to every job applicant during an extensive orientation program in Houston.
When employees are injured or killed in Iraq, officials at Halliburton headquarters say they are committed to helping the workers and their families.
â€œThe work KBR employees perform in Iraq is often done under harsh and difficult conditions,â€ Halliburton spokeswoman Cathy Mann said in a written reply to questions from the Tribune. â€œTherefore, KBR recognizes the importance of helping its employees and their families during difficult times and is committed to do so in any way possible.â€
But former KBR workers and their families, some of whom are suing KBR and Halliburton over the deaths of their loved ones, say they got little help.
â€œIt was like pulling teeth trying to find out from KBR what happened to Steve,â€ said Hulett, whose husband was among six KBR employees killed when their convoy was ambushed along a route where fighting between Iraqi insurgents and U.S. forces had been raging for several days. â€œLater on, I asked KBR to continue paying my health insurance – I couldnâ€™t afford the COBRA for it, almost $800 per month. They refused. They wouldnâ€™t help.â€
Richard Zbryski, whose brother was a KBR truck driver, said company officials â€œwere going to dump my brother at the airport, and that was the extent of them taking care of itâ€-until he said he contacted several New York newspapers about the story. Soon afterward, Zbryski said, KBR agreed to cover his brotherâ€™s funeral costs.
Ray Stannard, a former KBR truck driver who was among 11 contractors wounded in the same ambush in which Hulett was killed, said he still suffers nightmares and flashbacks from that harrowing day and wonders if he might be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder.
â€œThe first day I got back, I thought I was going to get help from KBR,â€ said Stannard, 48, who now drives long-haul trucks out of El Paso, Texas. â€œA lot of us who survived that thing, we are all having nightmares. But they never even called us to follow up. When I got ahold of one of the KBR secretaries higher up, she said they had a lot of people who have gone through that, youâ€™re not anything different than anyone else.â€
The former KBR workers and their families said they had encountered criticism from skeptics who said the dead and injured workers ought to have known the dangers they were facing and deserved no special sympathy.
That attitude offends Steven Schooner, a law professor at George Washington University and a former military officer who is an expert on Pentagon procurement and the use of private contractors to support U.S. military operations.
â€œPeople think of the contractors, alive or dead, as profiteers, adventurers, mercenaries or the like, whereas anyone in uniform who dies is a patriot and a hero,â€ Schooner said. â€œThatâ€™s appalling. These are workers who are there to enable the U.S. military to do its job. And when the going got tough, they didnâ€™t go home.â€